Intangible-driven performance: Two decades searching for the Philosopher's Stone

  • Elena A. Shakina International Laboratory of Intangible-driven Economy, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Campus in St. Petersburg, Russia Russia
  • Mariya A. Molodchik Faculty of Economics, Management, and Business Informatics;International Laboratory of Intangible-driven Economy, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Campus in Perm, Russia
  • Petr A. Parshakov Faculty of Economics, Management, and Business Informatics;International Laboratory of Intangible-driven Economy, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Campus in Perm, Russia


The study offers a structural literature review on the twenty years the evolution of the fast-growing research topic of intellectual capital (IC) and intangible-driven performance. Despite a rather short independent history, the IC concept has undergone a substantial transformation, bringing to the discussion vast empirical and methodological literature. Several endeavors carrying out literature review studies could only partially satisfy the needs of the systematization of the relevant research. Hence, there is still a large room for such kind of analysis due to the increasing number of new papers published in the area and puzzle of IC-related sophistications. To draw a holistic picture of the landscape of IC and associated corporate performance, this study departures from the mixed research methodology embracing elements of machine-learning tools and in-depth qualitative interpretation of obtained results and critical discussion of the most influential studies in the field. Our findings demonstrate that four professional outlets selected for the examination have generated four relatively isolated research topics: “Human capital and performance”, “Knowledge sharing, organizational learning: processes that drive performance”, “IC and knowledge management for business performance”, “Measurement, disclosure of IC and knowledge for business performance”. All these research lines are welcomed by all leading journals in the field, having high potential to create a dense flow of conceptual and empirical contributions and practical value for a knowledge-intensive business.

Ключевые слова:

literature review, intangible-driven performance, text-mining, topic modeling


Данные скачивания пока недоступны.



Abeysekera I. 2006. The project of intellectual capital disclosure: Researching the research. Journal of Intellectual Capital 7 (1): 61–75.

Alpkan L., Bulut C., Gunday G., Ulusoy G., Kilic K. 2010. Organizational support for intrapreneurship and its interaction with human capital to enhance innovative performance. Management Decision 48 (5): 732–755

Ardichvili A., Page V., Wentling T. 2003. Motivation and barriers to participation in virtual knowledge-sharing communities of practice. Journal of Knowledge Management 7 (1): 64–77.

Arun R., Suresh V., Veni Madhavan C. E., Narasimha Murthy M. N. 2010. On finding the natural number of topics with latent Dirichlet allocation: Some observations. In: M. J. Zaki, J. Xu Yu, B. Ravindran, V. Pudi (eds). Advances in Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining, 391–402. Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

Asmussen C. B., Møller C. 2019. Smart literature review: A practical topic modeling approach to exploratory literature review. Journal of Big Data 6 (1).

Barajas A., Shakina E., Fernández-Jardón C. 2017. Acceleration effect of intangibles in the recovery of corporate performance after-crisis. Research in International Business and Finance 42: 1115–1122.

Barney J. 1991. Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management 17 (1): 99–120.

Bellucci M., Marzi G., Orlando B., Ciampi F. 2020. Journal of Intellectual Capital: A review of emerging themes and future trends. Journal of Intellectual Capital (ahead-of-print).

Bhatt G. D. 2001. Knowledge management in organizations: Examining the interaction between technologies, techniques, and people. Journal of Knowledge Management 5 (1): 68–75.

Bontis N. 1998. Intellectual capital: An exploratory study that develops measures and models. Management Decision 36 (2): 63–76.

Bontis N., Keow W. C. C., Richardson S. 2000. Intellectual Capital and Business Performance in Malaysian industries. Journal of Intellectual Capital 1 (1): 85–100.

Bontis N., Fitz-enz J. 2002. Intellectual capital ROI: A causal map of human capital antecedents and consequents. Journal of Intellectual Capital 3 (3): 223–247.

Burgman R., Roos G. 2004. Measuring, managing, and delivering value performance in the public sector. International Journal of Learning and Intellectual Capital 1 (2): 132–149.

Cao J., Xia T., Li J., Zhang Y., Tang S. 2009. A density-based method for adaptive LDA model selection. Neurocomputing 72 (7–9): 1775–1781.

Chen M.-C., Cheng S.-J., Hwang Y. 2005. An empirical investigation of the relationship between intellectual capital and firms' market value and financial performance. Journal of Intellectual Capital 6 (2): 159–176.

Cook S., Brown S. 1999. Bridging epistemologies: The generative dance between organizational knowledge and organizational knowing. Organization Science 10 (4): 381–400.

Cuozzo B., Dumay J., Palmaccio M., Lombardi R. 2017. Intellectual capital disclosure: A structured literature review. Journal of Intellectual Capital 18 (1): 9–28.

Darroch J. 2005. Knowledge management, innovation, and firm performance. Journal of Knowledge Management 9 (3): 101–115.

Delbecque V., Bounfour A., Barreneche A. 2015. Intangibles and value creation at the industrial level: Delineating their complementarities. In: В A. Bounfour, T. Miyagawa (eds). Intangibles, Market Failure and Innovation Performance, 27–56. Springer International Publishing: N.Y.

Deveaud R., SanJuan E., Bellot P. 2014. Accurate and effective latent concept modeling for ad hoc information retrieval. Document Numérique 17 (1): 61–84.

Dumay J. 2016. A critical reflection on the future of intellectual capital: From reporting to disclosure. Journal of Intellectual Capital 17 (1): 168–184.

Dumay J., Garanina T. 2013. Intellectual capital research: A critical examination of the third stage. Journal of Intellectual Capital 14 (1): 10–25.

Dumay J., Guthrie J. 2019. Reflections on interdisciplinary critical intellectual capital accounting research: Multidisciplinary propositions for a new future. Accounting, Auditing Accountability Journal 32 (8): 2282–2306.

Dumay J., Guthrie J., Ricceri F., Nielsen C. 2017. The Past, Present, and Future for Intellectual Capital Research: An Overview. Routledge: Abingdon.

Dumay J., La Torre M., Farneti F. 2019. Developing trust through stewardship: Implications for intellectual capital, integrated reporting, and the EU Directive 2014/95/EU. Journal of Intellectual Capital 20 (1): 11–39.

Edvinsson L., Malone M. 1997. Intellectual Capital: Realizing Your Company's True Value by Finding Its Hidden Brainpower. HarperCollins: N.Y.

Ferraris A., Mazzoleni A., Devalle A., Couturier J. 2019. Big data analytics capabilities and knowledge management: Impact on firm performance. Management Decision 57 (8): 1923–1936.

Grant R. M. 1991. The Resource-Based Theory of Competitive Advantage: Implications for Strategy Formulation. Available at:

Greve H. R. 2003. A behavioral theory of RD expenditures and innovations: Evidence from shipbuilding. The Academy of Management Journal 46 (6): 685–702.

Griffith D. A. 2010. An analytical perspective on sporting events attendance: The 2007–2008 US NCAA college bowl games. Applied Geography 30 (2): 203–209.

Guthrie J., Petty R. 2000. Intellectual capital: Australian annual reporting practices. Journal of Intellectual Capital 1 (3): 241–251.

Guthrie J., Petty R., Yongvanich K., Ricceri F. 2004. Using content analysis as a research method to inquire into intellectual capital reporting. Journal of Intellectual Capital 5 (2): 282–293.

Hernaus T., Cerne M., Connelly C., Poloski Vokic N., Škerlavaj M. 2019. Evasive knowledge hiding in academia: When competitive individuals are asked to collaborate. Journal of Knowledge Management 23 (4): 597–618.

Holste J. S., Fields D. 2010. Trust and tacit knowledge sharing and use. Journal of Knowledge Management 14 (1): 128–140.

Inkinen H. 2015. Review of empirical research on intellectual capital and firm performance. Journal of Intellectual Capital 16 (3): 518–565.

Intangible Asset Market Value Study. 2017. Ocean Tomo. [Electronic resource]. (accessed: 11.05.2020).

Ittner C. D., Larcker D. F. 2001. Assessing empirical research in managerial accounting: A value-based management perspective. Journal of Accounting and Economics 32 (1): 349–410.[01]00026-X

Jasimuddin S. M., Klein J. H., Connell C. 2005. The paradox of using tacit and explicit knowledge: Strategies to face dilemmas. Management Decision 43 (1): 102–112.

Krippendorff K. 1980. Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology.SAGE: Thousand Oaks

Kristandl G., Bontis N. 2007. Constructing a definition for intangibles using the resource-based view of the firm. Management Decision 45 (9): 1510–1524.

Le P. B., Lei H. 2019. Determinants of innovation capability: The roles of transformational leadership, knowledge sharing, and perceived organizational support. Journal of Knowledge Management 23 (3): 527–547.

Lin H., Lee G. 2005. Impact of organizational learning and knowledge management factors on e-business adoption. Management Decision 43 (2): 171–188.

Ming-Chin Ch., Shu-Ju Ch., Yuhchang H. 2005. An empirical investigation of the relationship between intellectual capital and firms' market value and financial performance. Journal of Intellectual Capital 6 (2): 159–176.

Mittal S., Dhar R. L. 2015. Transformational leadership and employee creativity: Mediating role of creative self-efficacy and moderating role of knowledge sharing. Management Decision 53 (5): 894–910.

Molodchik M., Jardon C. M., Bykova A. 2019. The performance effect of intellectual capital in the Russian context: Industry vs. company level. Journal of Intellectual Capital 20 (3): 335–354.

Molodchik M., Jardon C. M. 2017. Intellectual capital as an enhancer of product novelty: An empirical study of Russian manufacturing SMEs. Journal of Intellectual Capital 18 (2): 419–436.

Molodchik M., Shakina E., Barajas A. 2014. Metrics for the elements of intellectual capital in an economy driven by knowledge. Journal of Intellectual Capital 15 (2): 206–226.

Molodchik M., Shakina E., Bykova A. 2012. Intellectual capital transformation evaluating model. Journal of Intellectual Capital 13 (4): 444–461.

Nahapiet J., Ghoshal S. 1998. Social capital, intellectual capital, and the organizational advantage. The Academy of Management Review 23 (2): 242–266.

Naidenova I., Parshakov P. 2013. Intellectual capital investments: Evidence from panel VAR analysis. Journal of Intellectual Capital 14 (4): 634–660.

Osinski M., Selig P. M., Matos F., Roman D. J. 2017. Methods of evaluation of intangible assets and intellectual capital. Journal of Intellectual Capital 18 (3): 470–485.

Parshakov P., Shakina E. 2020. Do companies disclose intellectual capital in their annual reports? New evidence from explorative content analysis. Journal of Intellectual Capital 21 (6) 853–871.

Pedro E., Leitão J., Alves H. 2018. Back to the future of intellectual capital research: A systematic literature review. Management Decision 56 (11): 2502–2583.

Petty R., Guthrie J. 2000. Intellectual capital literature review: Measurement, reporting, and management. Journal of Intellectual Capital 1 (2): 155–176.

Popkova E. G., Sergi B. S. 2020. Human capital and AI in industry 4.0. Convergence and divergence in social entrepreneurship in Russia. Journal of Intellectual Capital 21 (4): 565–581.

Riege A. 2005. Three-dozen knowledge-sharing barriers managers must consider. Journal of Knowledge Management 9 (3): 18–35.

Serenko A., Bontis N. 2013. Investigating the current state and impact of the intellectual capital academic discipline. Journal of Intellectual Capital 14 (4): 476–500.

Shakina E., Barajas A. 2012. The relationship between intellectual capital quality and corporate performance: An empirical study of Russian and European companies. Economic Annals 57 (192): 79–97.

Shakina E., Barajas A. 2014. Value creation through intellectual capital in developed European markets. Journal of Economic Studies 41 (2): 272–291.

Shakina E., Barajas A. 2015. Intangible-intensive profile of a company: The key to outperforming. Journal of Intellectual Capital 16 (4): 721–741.

Shakina E., Barajas A. 2016. Intangible-intensive profiles of companies: Protection during the economic crisis of 2008–2009. Journal of Intellectual Capital 17 (4): 758–775.

Shakina E., Molodchik M. 2014. Intangible-driven value creation: Supporting and obstructing factors. Measuring Business Excellence 18 (3): 87–100.

Silge J., Robinson D. 2016. Text mining and analysis using tidy data principles in R. The Journal of Open Source Software 1 (3): 37.

Smith E. A. 2001. The role of tacit and explicit knowledge in the workplace. Journal of Knowledge Management 5 (4): 311–321.

Snyder H. 2019. Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. Journal of Business Research 104: 333–339.

Stern J. M., Shiely J. S., Ross I. 2001. The EVA Challenge: Implementing Value-Added Change in an Organization. Wiley and Co: N.Y.

Teece D. J., Pisano G., Shuen A. 1997. Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal 18 (7): 509–533.

Yahya S., Goh W. 2002. Managing human resources toward achieving knowledge management. Journal of Knowledge Management 6 (5): 457–468.

Young S. D., O'Byrne S. F. 2000. EVA and Value-Based Management: A Practical Guide to Implementation. McGraw Hill Professional: N.Y.

Zaratiegui J. M. 2002. What does profit mean for Alfred Marshall? International Journal of Applied Economics and Econometrics 10 (3): 381–402. Available at:

Zucker L. G., Darby M. R., Brewer M. B. 1998. Intellectual human capital and the birth of U.S. biotechnology enterprises. American Economic Review 88 (1): 290–306.

Как цитировать
Shakina, E. A., Molodchik, M. A., & Parshakov, P. A. (2020). Intangible-driven performance: Two decades searching for the Philosopher’s Stone. Российский журнал менеджмента, 18(3), 433–456.